Photo Credit: Kristin Cavallari/instagram
Former NFL quarterback Jay Cutler has taken to his podcast, Take It Outside, to publicly challenge a bold assertion made by ex-wife Kristin Cavallari—that she walked away from their 2022 divorce agreement with “not a penny.” The remarks have ignited a heated dispute, drawing attention across talk shows, fan forums, and Reddit threads.
The Accusation: Zero Dollars
On June 18, 2025, during an episode of Honestly Cavallari: The Headline Tour, Cavallari told listeners she received no financial support from Cutler post-divorce. She asserted, “I have never gotten a penny from my ex-husband. I didn’t get any money from our divorce, so let’s just clear that up,” emphasizing her independence as the sole, self-funded owner of her lifestyle brand Uncommon James.
Cutler’s Response: “Borderline Slander”
In a fiery response on his August 19 podcast episode, Cutler called Cavallari’s claim “reckless,” “irresponsible,” “insanity,” and “borderline slander.” He underscored that no Tennessee judge would approve a divorce agreement giving him every dollar from their seven-year marriage while she received nothing. Drawing on his substantial NFL earnings, he stated: “She got a lot, a lot, a lot of [dollar] bills.” Though he declined to reveal specific figures, he insisted the settlement was more than adequate to allow her to “live comfortably for the rest of your life”.
The Legal Record: A 67-Page Divorce Decree
Cutler’s remarks reference a court-appointed divorce decree—allegedly a detailed 67-page document—that outlines the financial breakdown of the settlement. He insists that Cavallari’s remark contradicts this legal record and misrepresents the facts.
Business as Marital Asset
Adding another dimension to the argument, Cutler pointed out that Uncommon James—Cavallari’s jewelry and skincare venture—was created during their marriage and thus should have been considered a marital asset. This suggests she benefited indirectly through ownership of a business launched while they were still together.
Behind the Tweets: Reddit Reacts
Fans and online commenters have been vocal. On Reddit, one user weighed in:
“Her disappearing from Vegas shows made more sense once everyone realized something was wrong.”
Others view this clash as a prelude to further drama. The tension seems emblematic of a deeply personal and unresolved fallout that continues to capture public fascination.
Insider View: Gaslighting or Misinterpretation?
Amid the escalating dispute, a source close to Cavallari suggested that Cutler’s rebuttal may be a gaslighting tactic, deliberately twisting her words to control the narrative. The insider said Cutler’s statements were manipulated “into something completely different than what Kristin was initially saying”, framing the conflict as more than just a legal disagreement—it’s a battle over public perception.
What’s Next? Public Silence from Cavallari
As of now, Cavallari has not issued any official response to Cutler’s statements or the insider claims. The online chatter and media frenzy leave the door open for further revelations—whether through her own podcast or other outlets.
Final Thoughts
This public clash serves as a reminder that even seemingly closed chapters can erupt into controversy when personal and financial pride collide. As both figures remain influential—Cavallari as a businesswoman and media personality, Cutler with his sports legacy and podcast platform—the fallout continues to resonate with audiences and fans.